Exercise Set 15
IMPERFECT COMPETITION


I. Objectives


II. Data


III. Questions

  1. Select values for each firm's sales (say, in millions of dollars).
  2. Compute the market share for each firm.
  3. Obtain the HHI value for the industry.
  4. Suppose Firms B and C merge. Compute the market shares of Firm A and the newly-formed firm. Obtain the corresponding HHI value.
    [Assume that the sales of Firm A have not changed, and that sales of the merged entity is the sum of the sales of B and C prior to the merger.]
  5. From the preceding, we note that when firms in an industry merge, the HHI for the industry will [ increase / decrease / remain the same ].
  6. If Firm A were a monopoly, the industry's HHI would be ______________. Explain.
  7. Suppose an industry has 3 firms and it has an HHI value of around 3500. Does the fairly high HHI value indicate that the firms are unlikely to compete vigorously in the market? Discuss critically, noting the importance of the presence -- or absence -- of barriers to entry in the industry.

IV. Additional Questions

  1. Consider the Chicago-Detroit flight for Continental Airlines.
  2. The price of oil, an important input for airlines, increases slightly. You observe, however, that Northwest Airlines does not increase its ticket price.

  3. How is the HHI computed? If the merger of two large firms in an industry results in an HHI greater than 1800, the Department of Justice might frown upon the merger. Why?

  4. Consider a recent example of merger activity (in the U.S. or in some other country).
    1. What is the rationale for the merger?
    2. Is the merger likely to lead to higher prices for consumers? Explain how a merger might possibly lead to lower prices.

  5. Which of the following is true about a firm in monopolistic competition in the long run?
    (a) The firm makes zero profits
    (b) Price equals marginal cost
    (c) The demand curve is tangential to the AC curve
    (d) All of the above
    (e) Both (a) and (c)

  6. In an oligopoly
    (a) A firm's actions affect other firms in the industry
    (b) A firm takes the market price as given
    (c) There are several firms
    (d) A firm faces a horizontal demand curve

  7. For a firm in monopolistic competition, at the optimal output level,
    (a) Price is greater than marginal cost
    (b) Price is less than marginal revenue
    (c) Marginal revenue is equal to marginal cost
    (d) Both (b) and (c)
    (e) Both (a) and (c)

  8. In contestable markets,
    (a) Firms cannot recover their fixed costs if they exit the industry
    (b) Firms will make economic profits in the long run
    (c) Barriers to entry keep out potential entrants
    (d) Both (a) and (b)
    (e) None of the above

  9. A cartel is
    (a) A group of oligopolists that try to behave like a monopoly and split the benefits among themselves
    (b) A government-approved organization for the exchange of technical information among firms
    (c) A form of competition among oligopolists
    (d) A regulated industry that is officially permitted to set the price of its good above long-run average cost.

  10. Which of the following is true about a firm's optimal price and output in monopolistic competition in the long run?
    (a) Price equals average cost.
    (b) The firm makes positive economic profits, but zero accounting profits.
    (c) Marginal cost equals average cost.
    (d) Both (a) and (b)
    (e) Both (b) and (c)

  11. In an oligopoly
    (a) There are no barriers to entry and exit.
    (b) Firms consider the prices set by their rivals when making their own decisions.
    (c) Firms make zero profits in the long run.
    (d) Both (a) and (b) are true.
    (e) Both (a) and (c) are true.


Answers to selected questions in Section IV:

	5e	6a	7e	8e	9a	10a     11b